Thursday, May 17, 2012
Prompt # 6
My experience in a first grade classroom continues as before. The children are getting to know me, just by my presence, not because we have much interaction. I have noticed that much of the students' written work is phonetic. The teacher has a policy of not spelling any words for them, they must spell it phonetically if they do not know the correct spelling. It seems to me that this is very good practice for sound symbol relationship, but might reinforce bad spelling if this method is practiced for too long, but maybe for ESL students this is best. I have noticed one boy, who has was off task for quite a while. He appears to have special needs. He was peeling the paper off of crayons and playing instead of doing the writing assignment. Since I was monitoring the group, I attempted to get him back on task, but with no success. When the teacher was done with her reading group, she had him come sit by her. She worked with him one on one, with some success as far as I could tell from a distance. Again, the angry tone of the teacher was disturbing. I felt that clearly this boy was not up to par with his work, nor was he on task, but an angry tone did not seem appropriate. It seems that she could have had him come sit next to her without singling him out quite as noticeably. Many of the students are Spanish speaking, but most of them seem up to par with their English. It is difficult for me to tell if there are big gaps in achievement at this point. The students are all doing the same writing assignments. Reading group may be at different levels.My impression over all is that more sensitivity could be going on toward the students in general and probably also in regard to their backgrounds. The students generally get along and appear to interact well. Occasionally the teacher will have to separate two of them because they are fooling around, not because of conflicts.
.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Carol,
ReplyDeleteI have had time alone with the teacher I am assigned to which has afforded me the opportunity to ask a lot of questions. Overall, it sounds to me like there is a lot of stress at that school (you and I are at the same school), between teachers and administration. And, that stress seems to be carrying over into the classroom environment. My teacher has acknowledged that it is unfair of her to take some of that stress out on the kids, and she tries not to, but sometimes it just boils over. Not a good situation for anyone.....
Hi Carol and Toni,
ReplyDeleteI am also at the same school. Today was my first day meeting my students and my teacher. I was disappointed at the lack of work going on and also by the tone of the teacher. She was either stern and losing her temper one minute, or completely submissive and it was literally a "free-for-all" in there. I was just amazed at what I saw! Academia was an after thought.. having side conversations and fooling around was the most important thing for the class. I wonder if the stress of the situation there has something to do with the teacher's disposition today.
Great comments all around. Hopefully we'll spend time discussing the current "teacher climate" after we take a closer look at A nation at risk, the history of federal policy, and the media construction of teach persona and blaming.
ReplyDeleteHi Carol,
ReplyDeleteI am not in the same school but I was in a classroom last week where we had a fill-in teacher while the 2nd grade teacher was in a parent meeting. The fill in teacher was very rude to the students and one student in paticular. Right in front of one student who I asked if he would like to read with me, she said to me "Are you sure you want to do that?" I was shocked. That teacher had no filter. That little comment could affect that child in the long run.